Prop firm challenge
A prop firm profits when you fail. A challenge is a paid evaluation on a simulated account. At Topstep in 2025, 16.8% of challenges passed and 0.71% of funded traders moved to a live account. Backtest the strategy before you pay for tries.
Prop firm challenge vs Backtoast
| Prop firm challenge | Backtoast | |
|---|---|---|
| You pay | A fee per try | Two full tests for $99 |
| Capital | Simulated | Ours |
| Paid from | Simulated, even when funded | Real trading |
| Your share | Usually 80% to 90%, with caps | 30%, uncapped |
| Markets | Futures, or forex and CFDs | Stocks, options, futures, forex, crypto |
| Holding | Many force you flat by the close or weekend | Any holding period |
| Loss limits | Daily and max loss, open trades included | None |
Backtoast
Backtoast is your best shot at a strategy that actually works. Drafts assess and improve your trade across a dozen+ dimensions, drawing on known winning strategies and at no full-test cost. A full test is the most rigorous backtest publicly available. Two full tests are $99. Pass and we'll automatically offer to license your strategy at an uncapped 30% profit share with no deposit. The non-exclusive license lets you take it to a prop firm too.
How a prop firm challenge works
You pay for an account size and trade it to a profit target without breaking a daily or max loss limit. Topstep's 50K Combine needs $3,000 profit before a $2,000 max loss that trails your end-of-day balance and counts open trades, and it costs $49 a month plus a $149 activation fee. FTMO's 2-Step needs 10% then 5%, with a 5% daily and 10% max loss and at least four trading days.
Most firms add a consistency rule that caps your best day's share of the profit (55% at Topstep), and many ban trading the news or holding over the weekend.
Prop firm challenge pass rates
In 2025, 16.8% of Topstep's challenges passed, 51.8% of its traders reached a simulated funded account (many buy several tries), 33.3% of those got a payout, and 0.71% moved to a live account. Across 10 firms and 100,000 traders, FPFX Tech found 14% got funded and 7% got paid.
What a pass gets you
A pass usually gets you another simulated account. FTMO's terms say "No actual trading is taking place," and Topstep's terms say simulated trades "are not made in live markets." Fees are a prop firm's revenue, and payouts are its cost. In 2025 FTMO's revenue rose 31% and its net profit fell 59%, after rewards owed to traders ran 82% over what it had set aside.
Prop firm risks
FTMO's terms say "None of the Services are subject to laws regulating the financial sector," and FTMO decides at its own discretion what counts as a forbidden practice and can cancel the rewards. Firms close too, and True Forex Funds shut in 2024 citing insolvency. The CFTC lists "the opportunity to trade with a proprietary trading firm's money and share the profits" among forex fraud lures.
Are prop firms worth it
Only with extreme caution. Backtest the strategy before you pay for tries. Backtoast drafts assess and improve your trade across a dozen+ dimensions, drawing on known winning strategies and at no full-test cost, and passing strategies earn a 30% profit share on live capital with no deposit.
Figures from Topstep's 2025 risk disclosure, plans and terms, FTMO's terms and trading objectives, FTMO's 2025 accounts via CzechCrunch, FPFX Tech via Finance Magnates, True Forex Funds via Trade Informer, and the CFTC, checked November 2026. Lowest prices per try are on cheapest prop firms for 2026.
99% of trading strategies fail. Test yours.
Pass and we'll automatically offer to license your strategy at a 30% profit share.
Run the test