Stan Weinstein stage analysis
Stage analysis splits a stock's cycle into four stages on a weekly chart and buys the breakout from the stage 1 base into stage 2, the advance. Stan Weinstein published it in Secrets for Profiting in Bull and Bear Markets in 1988. Backtoast's run on US stocks failed our test, losing 2.6% a year over 149 trades.
| Strategy | Trades | A year | Test |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stage 2 breakout | 149 | −2.6% | Failed |
Stan Weinstein stage analysis
Stage 1 is the base, stage 2 the advance, stage 3 the top and stage 4 the decline. Weinstein reads them against the 30-week moving average, which he found “the best one for long-term investors.”
He enters on a buy stop at a high-volume breakout and never buys below a falling 30-week average. He sets a protective sell stop under the base and trails it up.
The run used weekly bars of liquid US stocks and held up to ten at a time.
The Minervini trend template screens for the same stage 2 with daily averages, and the Darvas box buys breakouts from a trading box.
When it works
Weinstein buys stage 2 and shorts stage 4, so the method covers bull and bear markets. Stage 2 buying makes its money in a rising market and loses in corrections, when breakouts fail back into the base.
Thomas Bulkowski's own trades from 1987 to 2010 averaged 13.2% buying in stage 1, 4.1% in stage 2 and −8.3% in stage 4. You can quick-check the stage 4 short side in a draft.
Origins
Weinstein edited The Professional Tape Reader, a newsletter built on stage analysis, and founded Global Trend Alert in 1990. He said he started from Edwards and Magee's chart patterns and added moving averages.
99% of trading strategies fail. Test yours.
Pass and we'll automatically offer to license your strategy at a 30% profit share.
Run the test