Options
Mark Spitznagel's tail hedge
Mark Spitznagel's Universa Investments runs a tail hedge (crash insurance for a stock portfolio) with a monthly roll of S&P 500 puts about 30% out of the money. Most months the puts expire worthless, but in the March 2020 crash Universa reported a 3,612% return on invested capital. Backtoast backtests tail hedges on S&P 500 options.
| Crash | S&P 500 | Universa |
|---|---|---|
| October 2008 | −16.9% in the month | +65% to +115% |
| August 24, 2015 | −3.9% on the day | +20% |
| March 2020 | −12.4% in the month | +3,612% |
| April 2025 | −18.9% from the February high | About +100% |
How the tail hedge works
A put gives you the right to sell at its strike price, so an S&P 500 put pays when the index falls below the strike. In The Dao of Capital (2013), Spitznagel's rule spends 0.5% of the portfolio each month on two-month S&P 500 puts about 30% out of the money and keeps the rest in the index. At an S&P 500 of 6,000 that's a 4,200 strike, and each month the rule rolls the puts into new two-month contracts.
The puts gain value well before the index reaches the strike, because a fall brings the strike closer and lifts implied volatility (the expected swing priced into options).
Spitznagel buys the puts to cut the volatility tax (his term for the negative compounding of large losses). Lose 50% one year and make 100% the next and you average 25% a year, but you're back where you started. In a February 2018 Universa paper he worked out that capping every yearly S&P 500 loss at 15% over the prior 20 years would have raised its compound annual return from 7.2% to 11.08%. The Wall Street Journal reported a 12.3% compound annual return from March 2008 to February 2018 for a portfolio of 3.3% Universa and 96.7% S&P 500.
What 3,612% means
Universa's 3,612% is on invested capital (the slice in puts). Brandon Yarckin of Universa gave Bloomberg the example of a client who hedged $1 billion of stocks with $5 million in January 2020, and March turned the $5 million into $205 million. Bloomberg Opinion's Aaron Brown put the March 2020 gain at 12.8% of the whole portfolio. At his estimated premium of 0.22% a month, that covers about five years of hedging. Saba Capital's Boaz Weinstein and former Citadel fixed income head Derek Kaufman said the method flatters Universa's results.
2008 financial crisis
In 2008 Universa bought puts on the S&P 500, Goldman Sachs and AIG and sold the Goldman and AIG puts after both stocks crashed. In October the S&P 500 fell 16.9%, its worst month since 1987, and the funds in Universa's Black Swan Protection Protocol were up 65% to 115%. Press reports put its 2008 return above 100%.
August 2015 flash crash
On August 24, 2015 the Dow fell more than 1,000 points at the open and the S&P 500 closed down 3.9%. The index was only 11% under its May record, and the Wall Street Journal reported Universa up about 20% on the day and about $1 billion for the week.
March 2020 COVID crash
In March 2020 the S&P 500 fell 12.4% and Universa reported 3,612% for the month and 4,144% for the first quarter. CalPERS, California's state pension fund, hired Universa in 2017 and dropped it in January 2020. Bloomberg reported that CalPERS missed out on more than $1 billion. It kept a second tail hedge, with LongTail Alpha, through March 31 and collected several hundred million dollars.
April 2025 tariff crash
Trump's tariff announcements sent the S&P 500 down 18.9% from its February 19 record to the April 8 close. On April 7 Spitznagel told MarketWatch, “I expect an 80% crash when this is over. I just don't think this is it.” An investor told Reuters Universa made about 100% in April, and Spitznagel declined to confirm it.
Does Spitznagel time the market?
No. The puts roll every month. In his 2018 paper he says avoiding stocks at high valuations has historically cut the volatility tax, but investors can't stomach it and end up buying high and selling low.
The Dao of Capital measures crash risk with his Misesian Stationarity Index, the market value of US companies divided by the replacement cost of their assets (close to Tobin's Q). He argues low Fed rates push it up, and a high reading means a distorted market due for a crash. In September 2025 the Wall Street Journal reported his call for the S&P 500 to rally to about 8,000 before a 1929-style crash. Stock bear market indicators compares valuations with faster signals like the 200-day break and VIX above 30.
Origins
Spitznagel grew up in Northport, Michigan, and at 16 started working for Everett Klipp, a veteran corn and soybean trader at the Chicago Board of Trade (CBOT). Klipp's motto, “You've got to love to lose,” meant taking every small loss right away and waiting for the big win. The Dao of Capital calls it Klipp's paradox.
Spitznagel bought his own CBOT seat at 22 and traded Treasury bond futures. In the 1994 bond crash, which blew up his idol Tom Baldwin, he cut every losing trade fast and finished with a profit. In late 1997 he was a proprietary trader at Treasury dealer Eastbridge Capital, and his cheap crash options paid off when Hong Kong's Hang Seng fell 23% in four days. His positions made even more in 1998 when Long-Term Capital Management collapsed.
In 1999 he and Nassim Taleb, later the author of The Black Swan, started Empirica Capital. Empirica made about 60% in 2000, lost money in 2001 and 2002 and closed in 2004. After a stint at Morgan Stanley's Process Driven Trading unit, Spitznagel started Universa in January 2007 with $300 million, and Taleb is its Distinguished Scientist. By June 2022 Universa managed $19.1 billion.
Spitznagel has a master's in mathematics from NYU's Courant Institute and a BA from Kalamazoo College. He wrote The Dao of Capital: Austrian Investing in a Distorted World (Wiley, 2013) and Safe Haven: Investing for Financial Storms (Wiley, 2021, foreword by Taleb). David Senra's Founders podcast covered The Dao of Capital in episode 70. Spitznagel and his wife Amy own Idyll Farms, a goat dairy and creamery in Northport.
Other tail hedgers
In March 2020 Vineer Bhansali's LongTail Alpha reported 929% on invested premium for its OneTail Hedgehog fund and 157% including reserve cash. Capstone Investment Advisors and Saba Capital also posted big March 2020 returns.
By March 23, 2020, Bill Ackman's Pershing Square had turned about $27 million of credit default swaps (insurance against corporate bond defaults) into $2.6 billion. It was a one-off pandemic hedge. Michael Burry's bet against subprime mortgage bonds, told in The Big Short, cost him years of premiums before it paid off.
Cambria's Tail Risk ETF (TAIL) lost 46% from its 2017 launch through 2025, and Simplify's Tail Risk Strategy ETF (CYA) lost 99.9% before it closed in March 2024.
Tail hedges on Backtoast
Backtoast's engine backtests a Spitznagel-style put roll alone or as a hedge on any strategy. The drafting feature tests strikes, expiries and hedge sizing, and flags edges smaller than costs, overfit rules and more. A tail hedge is a far out-of-the-money protective put, and Backtoast's run of Cboe's 5% version made 7.0% a year but failed our full tradeability audit.
Spitznagel's rule is from The Dao of Capital (Wiley, 2013) as quoted by The Felder Report, and the volatility tax from his February 2018 Universa paper The Volatility Tax. Returns come from the Wall Street Journal (2008, 2015 and 2018), Bloomberg (March 2020), Reuters via Hedgeweek (April 2025), Bloomberg (LongTail Alpha) and Chief Investment Officer (Pershing Square). The return math is from Bloomberg and Aaron Brown's May 29, 2020 column, CalPERS from Institutional Investor, the early career from Scott Patterson's Chaos Kings (2023) via Fortune, and the ETFs from Cambria's fact sheet and Bloomberg.
99% of trading strategies fail. Test yours.
Pass and we'll automatically offer to license your strategy at a 30% profit share.
Run the test